First of all, let me admit that I'm cheating twice with this post. It's inspired by the Springtime in Paris event that Erin from Still Life, With Cracker Crumbs and Lisa from Boondock Ramblings have on their blogs this spring.
Not all of the movies are available to me, though. For tomorrow, Erin and Lisa have planned to watch the 2022 movie "Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris" with Lesley Manville. I've seen some of that on TV, but not the whole movie, and I can't really remember all the details.
So, instead I went back 30 years before that movie and watched the TV movie "Mrs. 'arris Goes to Paris" (notice the tiny difference?) with the wonderful Angela Lansbury.
Being the rebel I am, I also don't post this on the same day as Thursday is my silent movie day, and being weird the way I am, I don't like to post twice on one day, I'm here today.
"Mrs. 'arris Goes to Paris" is based on Paul Gallico's book of the same title, at least in the USA. In the UK, the title was changed to "Flowers for Mrs Harris". I couldn't find out why although both titles make sense, also not why the apostrophe was dropped which referred to Mrs. Harris' dialect. I found the book on the Internet Archive and gave it a quick read as it is only 157 pages.
You can find the movie on YouTube, not the best quality, but watchable.
So, who is Mrs. Harris and why does she go to Paris?
Ada Harris is a hardworking London charwoman with a circle of wealthy clients.
After a short introduction of her and her friend Vi, also a char, on the bus, you see her arriving at Lady Dant's house where she finds two Dior gowns hanging on the wardrobe from which Lady Dant wants to choose one for the new Queen's coronation ball.
Mrs. Harris is blown away and asks how much a gown like that costs and is told it's £450 (I did a little check, in 1953 that would have been around $1260 which may give you an idea).
From now on Mrs. Harris is obsessed by the idea to own a dress by Dior. After winning the football pools, not the jackpot unfortunately, she feels she's off to a good start and begins scrimping and saving, denying herself pleasures like going to the movies or the pub.
It takes her three years to save up. Her plan is to fly to Paris, buy a dress and fly back the same evening.
She makes it to Dior and gets rejected by the manageress Madame Colbert, but her tears make Madame change her mind and she gets her a seat at the afternoon show, much to the resentment of the director and a wealthy customer. Her seat neighbor is a Marquis who's enchanted by her (being reminded of the kind char at the English school he attended when he was young) and who approves of Madame's refusal to remove her when the director demands it.
Mrs. Harris chooses an opulent pink dress shown by head model Natasha, but is devastated upon hearing that it will take a week to make it because she doesn't have the money to stay in Paris. Mme Colbert and Natasha convince André, the house's accountant who happens to be in love with Natasha, to let her stay with him.
However, the fittings have to be done in secret to avoid the director.
From there on, Mrs. Harris has an impact on all of her new friends' lives. She brings the Marquis and his daughter and granddaughter together again, she helps Natasha and André find their love for each other, and with the help of the Marquis she achieves acknowledgement for Mme Colbert's husband who died in the war as a member of the French resistance.
When the dress is ready, though, the director catches them out and orders her to leave and the dress to be destroyed.
Of course, her friends at Dior don't let her down and contact the Marquis who then goes to Christian Dior himself.
The last problem is that no one told Mrs. Harris about customs for which she of course doesn't have the money, but they also find a solution for that by advising her to simply tell the truth. Instead of a Dior carton, they put the dress in a cheap suitcase, and when Mrs. Harris tells the customs agent she has a Dior dress in there, he doesn't believe her and therefore doesn't even open the suitcase.
In the end, you see her hanging up the dress in her flat remembering Paris and the party her friends gave her - even if Vi doesn't believe her.
I have always loved Angela Lansbury (despite only having seen about two episodes of "Murder, She Wrote") and I think she was great for this part.
This isn't a deep movie, this is a bowl of comforting hot soup on a cold day, it celebrates kindness generating kindness, and for that I really like it.
You know there's a but now, don't you?
Let's compare it to the book and you will see that the movie strays here and there.
- In the book, Mrs. Harris goes to the dog races after winning the pools and puts £50 on a dog called "Haute Couture" which she regards as a sign. She loses, but shortly after she finds a diamond pin and gets a reward of £25, and that is a sign for her to keep saving, but not depend on luck. In the movie, there's just the diamond pin.
- In the book, there's no director whom they have to hide from.
- Madame Colbert's husband isn't dead. He works for the Foreign Office and never gets a promotion despite his good work. Mrs. Harris tells the Marquis about it and he can help with that.
- The Marquis mentions children who are "scattered and far removed". You don't get to see any of them, there is no reuniting scene. He and Mrs. Harris do talk about her love to flowers, especially geraniums, though.
- In the movie, Natasha has an abusive rich boyfriend who gets punched by André when he insults Natasha which then makes her realize she loves André. In the book, there's no boyfriend. André is in love with Natasha and she falls in love with him quickly, but they both think it's not mutual and don't dare saying anything until Mrs. Harris comes right out with it.
- The dress is completely different (in each movie I have seen, by the way). It is mentioned that it is a dress meant for a much younger woman, but it doesn't have Cinderella quality. In the book it's not puffy and it's from black velvet with jet beads - which I'm a sucker for, so I would really have liked to see that! - with the top being a froth of cream, pink and white chiffon, tulle, and lace.
- The biggest difference, however, in this movie is the happy ending. In the book (and other movies), Mrs. Harris lends the dress to one of her clients for one night, a budding actress who wants to impress a producer. Huge mistake. There's an accident and the dress gets burned badly. The actress goes off for a week without even leaving a real apology or any compensation.
Mrs. Harris goes home, hides the dress away in the suitcase because she can't bear looking at it longer and weeps until she gets disturbed by the insistent ringing of her doorbell. She opens the door to a messenger who brings her loads of boxes full of beautiful flowers (that's why I said both titles make sense) sent by her friends from Paris.
That's when she decides not having the dress repaired because what she has gained is not a dress, it's friendship, memories, experience, adventure, and love - and no one can take that from her.
So yeah, all of that is missing from this movie and maybe Angela Lansbury could have been a bit rougher around the edges, a bit grittier, a bit less glamorous looking at the end, but hey, sometimes a bowl of hot soup is just the thing you need.
Not deep, no big moral, just a bit of joy for everyone.